Should I Repair or Replace My AC? The Complete Decision Framework (2026)

This is the most common question we hear from Las Vegas homeowners, and it deserves a rigorous answer rather than a vague "it depends." The repair-or-replace decision has a real financial answer if you run the right numbers. The problem is that both contractors and online guides tend to oversimplify it — either pushing replacement (which is a larger ticket) or minimizing the long-term cost of continued repairs.

This guide gives you the actual framework. We cover the 5,000 Rule, the age factor specific to Las Vegas, refrigerant considerations, component repair costs, energy savings math, and a complete decision tree you can apply to your exact situation. By the end, you will know whether to repair or replace with confidence — and you will be able to evaluate any contractor recommendation against objective criteria.

If you are still deciding whether to replace your current system entirely, our Complete Guide to Replacing Your Air Conditioner in 2026 covers everything from new refrigerant rules to installation standards.

Why Las Vegas Changes the Repair-or-Replace Math

Every repair-or-replace framework you will find online was built around the national average: a system that lasts 15-20 years, runs 1,000-1,500 hours per year, and experiences moderate temperature stress. Las Vegas is categorically different, and plugging your situation into a national framework produces wrong answers.

Compressed System Lifespan

A Las Vegas air conditioner runs 12 to 18 hours per day during the May-through-September cooling season, accumulating 2,000 to 2,700 annual runtime hours. That is roughly the same wear a system in Portland accumulates in three to four years. Every component — compressor, capacitor, contactor, fan motor, control board — ages in proportion to runtime hours and thermal stress, not calendar years.

What this means practically: a 10-year-old Las Vegas system has experienced the equivalent lifecycle stress of a 30-to-40-year-old system in a mild climate. When national guides say "consider replacing if your system is 15 years old," Las Vegas homeowners should read that as 8 to 10 years. The failure curves match, but they arrive faster.

Accelerated Component Wear

Desert conditions create failure modes that simply do not exist in moderate climates:

• Sustained high-temperature operation: Running a compressor at 115°F ambient for 16 hours straight is fundamentally different from running it at 90°F for 8 hours. Capacitors fail faster, refrigerant pressure runs higher, and compressor oil breaks down more rapidly.
• Dust infiltration: Las Vegas haboobs and daily airborne particulates coat condenser coils and clog electrical components. A dirty condenser running in 115°F heat is a compressor under severe stress.
• Power quality: NV Energy grid stress during heat waves causes voltage fluctuations and brownouts that destroy capacitors and control boards. Las Vegas systems experience more surge-related component failures than moderate-climate systems.
• UV degradation: Over 300 sunny days per year degrade wiring insulation, capacitor casings, and plastic components at a rate that shocks technicians who relocate from other regions.

These factors mean that when a major component fails on a Las Vegas system, it rarely fails alone. Compressors draw excess amperage that burns contactors. Capacitor failures strain compressors. Dirty coils force refrigerant pressure changes that damage evaporator coils. Understanding this failure cascade is essential to evaluating whether a single repair is truly a single repair — or the first bill in a series.

The 5,000 Rule: Your First Decision Filter

The 5,000 Rule is the most widely cited heuristic in the HVAC industry, and it holds up well when applied correctly. The formula is simple:

Repair Cost × System Age in Years = Decision Number
If the Decision Number exceeds $5,000: Replace.
If the Decision Number is under $5,000: Repair is likely the better financial choice.

How to Apply It

Suppose your system is 9 years old and you need a new condenser fan motor. The repair estimate is $450. The calculation: $450 × 9 = $4,050. Under $5,000, so repair is likely the right call — provided no other factors override it (see below).

Now suppose the same 9-year-old system needs a compressor replacement. The repair estimate is $2,200. The calculation: $2,200 × 9 = $19,800. Far over $5,000 — replace.

The rule works because it incorporates both the size of the investment and the remaining lifespan of the system. A $600 repair on a new system is trivial. The same repair on an old system heading toward total failure is expensive, because you are paying for a repair that will likely be followed by additional repairs before the system dies anyway.

Limitations of the 5,000 Rule in Las Vegas

The 5,000 Rule was calibrated for national average system lifespans. In Las Vegas, because systems age faster, we recommend applying a modified threshold: use $4,000 instead of $5,000, or — more precisely — run the calculation with an "adjusted age" that accounts for the accelerated lifespan. If your system is 8 years old in Las Vegas, treat it as 10-12 years old for purposes of the calculation. This produces a more accurate decision recommendation given local conditions.

Repair Cost by Component: What You Are Actually Deciding

Before you can apply any decision framework, you need accurate repair cost data. Here are realistic Las Vegas ranges for the most common major AC repairs in 2026. These include parts and labor from a licensed contractor.

Component	Repair Cost Range	Notes
Compressor replacement	$1,500 – $3,000	Variable-speed units higher ($2,000–$3,500). Often covered by parts warranty if under 10 years.
Evaporator coil replacement	$800 – $2,000	Requires system evacuation and recharge. Higher for larger systems.
Condenser fan motor	$300 – $600	Common failure in Las Vegas heat. Usually a straightforward repair.
Capacitor replacement	$150 – $300	Most common Las Vegas repair. Single capacitors are toward the low end; dual run capacitors higher.
Contactor replacement	$200 – $400	Often replaced alongside capacitor during a service call.
Refrigerant recharge (R-410A)	$200 – $500	Does not fix the leak. Leak detection and repair add $150–$600. R-22 recharges are $400–$1,500+ due to scarcity.
Condenser coil replacement	$1,200 – $2,500	Required when coil is severely corroded or physically damaged.
Control board replacement	$400 – $900	More common in advanced systems with digital controls.
Blower motor replacement	$350 – $700	Variable-speed blower motors are higher ($600–$1,200).
Drain line clearing	$75 – $150	Minor maintenance item. If ignored causes water damage.

These ranges reflect standard single-family residential systems in 2026. Premium equipment (Lennox Signature Series, Carrier Infinity, Trane XV) carries higher parts costs. Always confirm that a written repair estimate includes the specific parts, labor, and any required refrigerant before authorizing work.

The Age Factor: What Your System's Age Actually Means

System Age Thresholds in Las Vegas

The following thresholds reflect the realities of desert climate operation, not national averages:

• Under 5 years old: Repair virtually any issue. The system has significant life remaining. Unless the compressor fails without warranty coverage on a budget unit, repair is almost always correct.
• 5 to 8 years old: Repair minor issues (capacitor, contactor, refrigerant recharge). For major components, apply the 5,000 Rule. If the system is in good overall condition, repair. If it has been unreliable, start getting replacement quotes to have ready.
• 8 to 12 years old: This is the decision zone. Every major repair warrants a replacement comparison. Apply the 5,000 Rule strictly, check the 50% ratio rule, and factor in energy savings potential. Replacement is often the right financial call in this range, particularly for major component failures.
• 12+ years old: Unless the repair is minor (under $300) and the system is otherwise in good shape, replacement is almost always the better investment. Systems this age in Las Vegas have accumulated extreme wear, and major repairs often trigger additional failures within 1-2 years.

Finding Your System's Age

The manufacture date appears on the data plate on your outdoor condenser unit, typically formatted as a serial number in which the first two digits represent the week and the next two represent the year of manufacture. Some brands use different formats — Carrier encodes the year in the first four digits of the serial number. If you cannot decode the serial number, search the manufacturer's website for their serial number date format or call a technician.

Do not rely on when you moved into the home. Previous owners may have replaced or not replaced the system during their occupancy.

The Refrigerant Factor: The Non-Negotiable

Refrigerant type can override every other factor in the repair-or-replace decision. This is one area where the answer is binary, not a matter of degree.

R-22 Systems: Replace Immediately

If your system uses R-22 refrigerant — also known as Freon — replace it. Full stop. R-22 production was phased out under the Clean Air Act, with the final production ban taking effect January 1, 2020. No new R-22 is manufactured in the United States. Only recycled and reclaimed supplies exist, and they are expensive: $400 to $1,500 per pound depending on availability, with most residential systems holding 3 to 10 pounds.

A single R-22 refrigerant recharge — which does not fix the leak causing the loss — can easily cost $1,200 to $4,000+. Meanwhile, the system's performance is degrading, its components are aging, and replacement parts are increasingly difficult to source. There is no scenario in which continued investment in an R-22 system makes financial sense.

You can identify R-22 systems by the data plate on your outdoor unit (look for "R-22" or "HCFC-22") or by the refrigerant identification label on the service ports. If the system was installed before 2010 and has never been replaced, there is a high probability it uses R-22.

R-410A Systems: Factor in the Phasedown Timeline

Systems using R-410A refrigerant are in a different position. R-410A is being phased down — not phased out — under the EPA's AIM Act, but it remains widely available and affordable for existing systems. The phasedown affects new production of equipment, not the availability of R-410A for servicing existing systems.

For R-410A systems, the refrigerant factor is neutral to slightly negative. You can still get refrigerant for these systems at reasonable prices for the foreseeable future, likely through the early-to-mid 2030s. However, be aware that as new equipment transitions to R-454B, the R-410A supply chain will gradually shift. If you have an R-410A system that is otherwise aging and experiencing failures, the long-term trajectory of refrigerant availability is one more reason to lean toward replacement rather than continued repair.

For a comprehensive look at the refrigerant transition, see our dedicated guide: R-454B Refrigerant: What Las Vegas Homeowners Need to Know in 2026.

The 50% Rule: When Repair Cost Crosses the Threshold

The 50% rule is straightforward: if the cost of a repair exceeds 50% of the cost of replacing your system with a comparable new unit, replacement is almost always the better financial decision.

Here is the logic. A new 3-ton, 16 SEER2 system installed in Las Vegas costs approximately $6,500 to $9,000. If your repair estimate for a compressor replacement is $2,500 — roughly 28-38% of that range — you are spending a substantial portion of the cost of a new system on a repair that provides zero efficiency improvement, zero warranty reset, and does not address any of the other aging components.

The 50% threshold is a minimum. A more conservative and often more accurate version: if any single repair exceeds 30% of replacement cost on a system that is over 8 years old, the replacement analysis deserves serious consideration.

The Hidden Cost of Continued Repairs

The 50% rule focuses on a single repair, but the real financial picture includes the expected repair trajectory. When a compressor fails on a 10-year-old system, it rarely fails in isolation. The failure was likely preceded by months of elevated refrigerant pressure that stressed the evaporator coil, excessive amperage draw that damaged the contactor, and hard cycling that wore down the capacitor. Replacing the compressor without addressing these related issues sets up a follow-on repair bill within 6 to 24 months.

When evaluating a major repair on an older system, ask the technician: "What other components are showing wear that I should be aware of?" A trustworthy technician will tell you. If the answer is "the contactor and capacitor both look marginal" or "the evaporator coil has micro-corrosion starting," those are inputs into your repair-or-replace decision, not separate conversations.

The Energy Savings Calculator: The Factor Most Homeowners Miss

Repair-or-replace decisions almost always focus on the immediate repair cost versus the system replacement cost. What they often omit is the value of the efficiency improvement a new system provides — value that accrues every month for the life of the replacement system.

How to Calculate Your Annual Savings

First, find your current system's SEER2 rating on the data plate or in your original paperwork. If your system predates the SEER2 standard (most systems installed before 2023), you will have a SEER rating. Convert it for comparison: SEER2 is roughly 15% lower than the equivalent SEER rating. For a detailed explanation of SEER2 standards and what they mean for your home, the U.S. Department of Energy's guide to central air conditioning provides authoritative guidance on efficiency ratings and their real-world impact on cooling costs.

The energy savings from upgrading are calculated as follows:

Savings % = (New SEER2 − Old SEER2) ÷ New SEER2 × 100

Practical examples:

Old System Rating	New System Rating	Estimated Energy Savings	Annual Savings (Las Vegas)*
10 SEER (8.7 SEER2)	20 SEER2	~57%	$900 – $1,400/year
13 SEER (11.3 SEER2)	18 SEER2	~37%	$550 – $850/year
14 SEER2	20 SEER2	~30%	$450 – $700/year
16 SEER2	20 SEER2	~20%	$300 – $450/year

*Las Vegas estimates based on average annual cooling energy use of $1,600–$2,500 for a 2,000 sq ft home, depending on insulation, ductwork quality, and usage patterns.

These savings directly offset the cost of replacement. A $7,000 replacement that saves $800 per year in electricity pays back its incremental cost — above what the repair would have cost — in 6 to 9 years, well within the system's lifespan. If you are also eligible for federal tax credits (up to $2,000 for qualifying heat pumps, up to $600 for standard AC) and NV Energy rebates ($200-$400), the payback period shortens further. When evaluating new equipment, look for ENERGY STAR certified air conditioning systems, which meet rigorous efficiency standards and often qualify for additional utility rebates.

For a full breakdown of current rebates and tax credits, see our Complete Guide to Replacing Your Air Conditioner in 2026.

The Decision Tree: A Clear Path to Your Answer

Run through each of the following questions in order. Stop at the first definitive answer.

Step 1: Refrigerant Type

Does your system use R-22 refrigerant?

• Yes: Replace. The analysis ends here.
• No (R-410A or newer): Continue to Step 2.

Step 2: Warranty Coverage

Is the failed component covered under an active manufacturer warranty?

• Yes: Repair. Covered compressor replacements and major component repairs are nearly always the right call financially.
• No: Continue to Step 3.

Step 3: System Age (Las Vegas-adjusted)

Is your system under 8 years old?

• Yes (under 5 years): Repair virtually any issue.
• Yes (5-8 years), minor issue under $500: Repair. Continue to Step 4 for major issues.
• No (8+ years): Continue to Step 4.

Step 4: The 5,000 Rule

Multiply repair cost by system age. Does the result exceed $5,000?

• Yes: Replace.
• No: Continue to Step 5.

Step 5: Repair-to-Replacement Ratio

Does the repair cost exceed 50% of what a new comparable system would cost? Does it exceed 30% on a system over 10 years old?

• Yes (either threshold): Replace.
• No: Continue to Step 6.

Step 6: Repair History

Has the system had two or more major repairs in the past three years?

• Yes: Replace. You are in the failure cascade phase.
• No: Continue to Step 7.

Step 7: Energy Savings Calculation

What is your current system's efficiency rating, and what would upgrading save you annually?

• Annual savings exceed $600 and system is 8+ years old: Replacement is likely the better financial decision when you factor in the combination of repair cost, remaining lifespan, and ongoing energy savings.
• Annual savings are moderate ($300-$600) and system is otherwise reliable: Repair, but plan for replacement in the next 2-3 years and budget accordingly.
• System is relatively new and efficient: Repair.

When Repair Is Clearly the Right Answer

There are scenarios where the decision is straightforward without working through the full framework:

• System is under 5 years old and under manufacturer warranty: Repair any issue. The system has the majority of its lifespan ahead, and warranty coverage means you are not paying full repair cost anyway.
• Capacitor or contactor failure on a system under 10 years old: These are consumable components that cost $150-$400 to replace. They are not signals of broader system failure, and replacement would be economically irrational.
• Refrigerant leak that has a clear, isolated cause (like a damaged line set): If the leak is in accessible copper tubing and not in the coil itself, a targeted repair is often cost-effective even on older systems.
• Compressor failure under warranty on an otherwise sound 5-8 year old system: Most quality compressors carry a 5-10 year parts warranty. Even a $3,000 compressor covered by warranty costs you only labor — typically $400-$700 — making repair the clear choice.
• System is functioning but inefficient: If your system is running and cooling adequately, do not replace it just because it is older. Replace when a specific failure triggers the decision framework, or when the energy savings calculation clearly favors replacement.

When Replacement Is Clearly the Right Answer

Equally, some situations make replacement the obvious answer:

• R-22 refrigerant, any age: Replace immediately. No further analysis needed.
• System is 15 or more years old: In Las Vegas, a 15-year-old system has experienced extraordinary stress. Major repair on a system this age means spending significant money on equipment that could fail completely within 1-2 years.
• Compressor failure, out of warranty, system is 10+ years old: This is the scenario where replacement almost always wins. A $2,000-$3,000 compressor replacement on a 10-year-old Las Vegas system is rarely a good financial decision.
• Multiple component failures in 2 years: When you have replaced the capacitor, contactor, and fan motor within the same 24-month period, the system is telling you it is near the end. Repair the next failure and you will likely face another within a year.
• System not maintaining temperature on design days: If your system runs nonstop on a 110-degree afternoon and still cannot reach your thermostat setpoint, it has likely lost significant capacity. This is a sign of either significant refrigerant loss, a failing compressor, or a system that was undersized from the start — all cases that warrant replacement evaluation.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long do AC systems actually last in Las Vegas?

In Las Vegas desert conditions, most residential central air conditioning systems last 8 to 12 years under regular maintenance. Well-maintained premium systems — particularly those with inverter-driven compressors — may last 12 to 15 years. Budget single-stage systems on the accelerated Las Vegas failure curve often require replacement at 8 to 10 years. The national average of 15 to 20 years does not apply to this market.

My contractor says I need a new compressor. Should I always replace instead?

Not automatically. First, check whether the compressor is under warranty. Lennox, Carrier, Trane, and other major brands offer 5-to-10-year parts warranties, and labor-only compressor replacement can cost as little as $400-$700 versus $2,000-$3,000 out-of-warranty. If the system is under 8 years old and under warranty, repair. If the system is over 10 years old and out of warranty, apply the 5,000 Rule — the answer is almost always replace. See our Lennox AC Repair guide for model-specific repair cost ranges.

What does a refrigerant recharge cost, and does it fix the problem?

A R-410A refrigerant recharge costs $200 to $500 for the refrigerant itself. But a recharge alone does not fix anything — it only restores the refrigerant level. The refrigerant leaked out through a failure somewhere in the system: a corroded coil, a leaking fitting, a damaged line. Leak detection and repair add $150 to $600. If the leak is in the evaporator coil itself, coil replacement costs $800 to $2,000. Always ask for a leak detection before authorizing a recharge — paying for refrigerant that will leak back out within months is money wasted.

Can I get a second opinion on a repair estimate?

Yes, and you should for any repair estimate over $500. A reputable HVAC company will stand behind their diagnosis. If a contractor discourages you from getting a second opinion or pressures you to decide immediately, that is a red flag — see our guide to choosing an HVAC contractor for the warning signs to watch for. Diagnostic fees typically run $79 to $150 per contractor, which is money well spent on a major repair decision.

If I replace my system, what efficiency level should I buy?

In Las Vegas, we recommend a minimum of 18 SEER2 for any replacement system. The combination of long cooling seasons, high electricity rates, and significant utility rebates for efficiency makes the incremental cost of a higher-efficiency unit pay back well. The best air conditioners for Las Vegas specifically — those with inverter-driven compressors that maintain performance at extreme temperatures — are covered in our Best Air Conditioners for Extreme Heat guide. Always request that your contractor perform a Manual J load calculation before sizing any replacement system.

Does home warranty coverage change the repair-or-replace calculation?

Yes, significantly. If you have a home warranty policy that covers HVAC, a covered compressor or coil replacement could cost you only your service deductible ($75 to $125 typically) versus the full repair cost. However, home warranties often have limitations: they may cover the part but not refrigerant, they may require their preferred contractors, and they sometimes depreciate component value on older systems. Read your policy carefully. If the home warranty covers the repair in full, repair is almost always the right call regardless of system age.

What is the right time of year to replace an AC in Las Vegas?

The ideal replacement window is February through April. You avoid the June-September peak season when installation crews are booked 3 to 4 weeks out, equipment costs can rise with demand, and you are not negotiating while sweating through a failed system. Spring replacement also means the new system is commissioned and running properly before peak heat arrives. If your system is aging and you know replacement is coming, planning it in the spring off-season is both less stressful and often less expensive.

Need HVAC Service in Las Vegas?

The Cooling Company is a family-owned Lennox Premier Dealer serving Las Vegas since 2011. With 740+ Google reviews and a 4.9/5 rating, our technicians provide transparent, upfront pricing with written quotes and back every installation with a workmanship warranty. Licensed, bonded, and insured (NV #0082413).

Call (702) 567-0707 or visit HVAC services, HVAC maintenance, heating, or AC repair for details.

Share This Page

• Share on Facebook
• Share on X
• Share on LinkedIn
• Share by Email